NC’s Supreme Court heard arguments about Blackbeard’s flagship media ownership

NEW BERN, N.C. — NC’s Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday over the rights to photos and video from the wreckage of the pirate Blackbeard’s flagship. The state’s highest court will rule which lower court will hear the case next.

Intersal, Inc,  a Florida-based company,  found the wreckage of the Queen Anne’s Revenge off the North Carolina coast in 1996. Intersal contends the state breached a contract giving the company some exclusivity to images.

The State denies breaking the contract with Intersal. New legislation was passed in an attempt to clarify which records lie in the public domain..

An Intersal attorney argued for a hearing in Business Court, where monetary damages can be awarded. State lawyers argue the case qualifies only for administrative court, where they say it’s been settled.

Sen. Norman Sanderson, R-Pamlico, said the department asked him and Sen. Jim Davis, R-Macon, to add the language to a substitute bill proposed in a Senate Judiciary Committee last week.

“I’m sure that it was brought forth because of the lawsuit,” Sanderson said, adding that he did not know of any judge that would allow the law to be applied retroactively in the state’s defense.

However, wreck’s explorers were skeptical to claims the law could not be used against them in court.

“In Intersal’s opinion, this bill is a blatant attempt to undercut both our contract in the settlement agreement as well as our legal action,” said John Masters, chairman of the board of Intersal. “Intersal will amend our filing to address this and await further developments.”

The company’s 1998 agreement — updated just two years ago — with the state also gives Intersal the rights to the wreck of the El Salvador, which sank in 1750. While the Queen Anne’s Revenge was found without any valuable booty, some loot may remain with the El Salvador, which Intersal could lay claim to.

Sanderson said he knew of no other pending cases the law could be applied to in the future, and said he was only passively following the legal battle over the wreck, which sits about a mile off the coast in a part of his district in Carteret County.

“There’s been a lot of horse trading going along with it,” Sanderson said. “I thought for a while they had some kind of compromise and now it has come up again.”

The bill is scheduled for debate in the Senate next week, and will also have to be approved by the House.

The wreck of Blackbeard’s ship has become a popular tourist destination for the state, including an exhibit at the North Carolina Maritime Museum in Beaufort.

 

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Widgetized Section

Go to Admin » appearance » Widgets » and move a widget into Advertise Widget Zone